Monday, November 16, 2026

BOTANY OF MADNESS, a psychologist and playwright's story of identity, destiny, in madness


BOTANY OF MADNESS
LEON ENGLER
(tr. Alexandra Roesch)
New Vessel Press (non-affiliate Bookshop.org link)
$17.95 all editions, preorder now for delivery 17 November 2026

Rating: 4.25* of five

The Publisher Says: A young man is gripped by one fear: that he'll lose his mind. In his family, mental illness has shaped lives for generations, and time in psychiatric wards has become almost a rite of passage.

His battle to avoid inheriting his grandmother’s suicidal behavior, his mother’s bipolar disorder, or his father's bouts with alcoholism and depression spurs him to flee Germany for New York, via Paris and Vienna, only to end up in just the kind of mental institution that so terrified him. But he works there as a psychologist rather than undergo treatment as a patient himself, and learns that a person is always more than a diagnosis.

In this picaresque novel, a potent blend of memoir and fiction, the protagonist is forced to confront the question he has avoided all his life: What is normal?

I RECEIVED A DRC FROM THE PUBLISHER VIA EDELWEISS+. THANK YOU.

My Review
: As a playwright and a psychologist, the author knows his narrative onions, knows his pungent harvest of stories to tell and techniques to tell them; but as a debut novelist, he did not reckon with how very important the human voice in an audience of any size's ear is.

The speeches are well joined, no lapses of craft, no spaces left by mistake or without thinking about what he's having the narrator say.

Because the narrator says A Lot.

Were this meditation on identity, mental illness, exploring who has permission to say "you! You're ill! You over there! You're fine;" who gets to be treated as though ill and whose treatment will be denied on what authority; were all these facets presented on a stage I'd rise clapping. As a novel/prose work (one can't ignore the stated autobiographical element, though it's not really obvious where the line blurs) it is significantly less likely to applaud. It's a story deeply felt. It comes through the narration with waves of fear, rising to what feels like a very heavy sea of self-involvement. Any narrator in a mental institution, describing his impostor syndrome as a major impediment to his ability to treat the agonies of others while suffering them himself, is going to be self-aware at an acutely fine level of discernment. That he goes on, putting on his Author hat in his source citations, to name-check Slavoj Žižek is so extra as to be next-level's extra.

The sort of words the narrator uses are all multivalent, meant to ring bells and pull out stops in memory's pipe-organ. I've found that many readers do not enjoy relatibe names, à la Milkman, it's very unpopular with many who also do not enjoy stream of consciousness narratives. In the example of this story, the work of character-building is mainly in the reader's hands. The story is all tell, little show; that's going to flatten characters whose interiority is not "normal" or evven readily discernible under very odd, offputting behaviors. It's a bit...rich...to use therapyspeak to wag a finger at reducing a person to a mental-health diagnosis then decline to present their interiority. Permaybehaps that's a stratagem. It is, so to speak, not an easy read.

Do I think it's worth y'all's expenditure of time and treasure? It was for me, in my present mood. I liked that tension between therapyspeak and the flattening of the characters with mental illnesses, because it points up that what are best practices now are not the easy and familiar labels. "Depressed" and "schizophrenic" and "suicidal" are fast, easy to remember, and reductive labels that the narrator flings about with gay abandon. He never refers to his family, the ones who imbued him with both the terror and the problem of mental illness, by any detail except their diagnosis.

Will that be true for you? Maybe not; maybe it's enough to hear about a playwright's story of identity, of self-definition, of questing for a framework of knowledge to hide his fear under and inside. It may be that reading about diagnoses is just too much for you, too raw, too far away, too much like the work you're not interested in doing.

Being among those who do not think like you can be disorienting and is usually more or less unpleasant until the rules of their game are clear. Among those who decide their diagnosis is their identity, their destiny even, can become too overwhelming to br borne.

I wonder if our psychological professional author is escaping by explaining.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.