A MURDEROUS BUSINESS, first Harriman & Mancini lesbian-led historical mystery

A MURDEROUS BUSINESS (Harriman & Mancini #1)
CATHY PEGAU
Minotaur Books (non-affiliate Bookshop.org link)
$14.99 ebook, available now

Rating: 4.25* of five

The Publisher Says: Cathy Pegau's sharp, captivating historical mystery about two women in turn-of-the-century New York solving murder and fighting the heteropatriarchy.

There can be a blurry line between what is ethical and what is legal.

Margot Baxter Harriman took the reins of B&H Foods after her father passed. It’s not easy being a business woman in 1912, but she is determined to continue what her grandparents started decades ago, no matter what it takes.

When Margot finds Mrs. Gilroy, her father’s former assistant, dead in the office with a half-finished note confessing to nebulous misdeeds, she seeks out help from a very discreet, private investigator to figure out what's going on. Her company, and her good name, depends on determining the truth, otherwise she could lose everything, including her freedom.

Loretta “Rett” Mancini has run her father’s investigation operation since he started becoming increasingly forgetful. When Margot offers her the chance to look into the potential scandal with B&H, she jumps at the chance.

But the more the two dig, the more it becomes clear that Margot's company may be too far lost...and her life is at stake.

I RECEIVED A DRC FROM THE PUBLISHER VIA NETGALLEY. THANK YOU.

My Review: Superior iteration of a sleuthing odd couple, platonic edition. The lesbian protagonists are each trying to prove themselves by solving this crime. Rett Mancini's life partner, a nurse called Ceecee, is not terribly filled out as a character, but she isn't backgrounded...her existence is a source of stress between Rett and her private-dick dad. Her mother's not fussed, interestingly, by having an "abnormal" daughter.

Margot inherits her father's food-canning business, and bashes her nose into the harsh reality that she lives in a gilded cage. The canning business is in crisis due to an adulteration scandal. In 1912, that was huge news: next to the Titanic's recent sinking, the still-new Food and Drug Administration (FDA as we know it today) was still rooting out abusive and dangerous practices in the US food chain because of the rampant fraud that led to its founding. Discovering her father's retired right-hand woman dead, inside the office she so recently left, with an unfinished note to Margot that lacks specificity but hints at skulduggery, Margot hires Rett at the moment Papa Mancini chucks her out of the family detective agency for being unnatural.

Margot needs the business to stay open, for practical and ego reasons. Rett needs the spondulix from Margot to live, and wants badly to show her homophobic father he's wrong about her ability to do the work despite being abnormal. Rett summons a common stage entertainer, magicianesque Shiloh, to assist with the details of solving Margot's case. There blooms a lovely fondness between those ladies, as wealthy, sheltered Margot begins her journey out of closet and cage...within limits, I'll wager, that will present problems as Margot is already trying to run the canning business and date a common entertainer on the sly. What could add more spice to a love than that?

Which leads me to explain my rating. This is a good, cozy mystery, set in a time of upheaval and possibility. Some of the very best US institutions were created; some people were freer than ever before; and some were not. My tribe, the queers, were decidedly not included among the social-loosening winners for very long. The excitement of ever-improving quality of life inventions and products was heady. A hefty dose of that comes through in the alternating narration of chapters between Margot and Rett. Unlike most series-starting novels, Author Pegau resists making the central sleuthing duo a couple...thank all those useless gods for that! It felt liberating, and lifted my opinion of a well-written, interestingly placed, but not really surprising story up a notch. Had the main duo been made a romantic couple I'd've rated it a 3.5 and relegated it to a short review to be forgotten.

It took vision for Author Pegau to see how much more good, positive story-developmental material there was in making the couples in her lesbian-demimonde asymmetric in almost every way, but still show how true and heartfelt their interconnectedness is.

Kudos, Author Pegau, and when's the next one coming? Put me on the list, please.